5th of Kislev, 5787 · Shabbat candles Fri, Nov 20 4:35 PM · Parashat Vayetzei
Chabad of Lamorinda

Learn › Jewish ideas › Big questions: purpose, suffering and the soul

Free Will in Judaism: Do We Really Choose?

What Judaism teaches about free will, how it fits with G-d knowing the future, and practical Chassidic tools for making good choices every day.

Part 15 of 24 · Life's big questions

On this page · 2 min read"Choose life"What is in our hands?If G-d knows the future, are we free?The daily struggleFree will and teshuvahLiving with free will

Judaism teaches that every person has free will: the power to choose between good and bad. This freedom is a basic principle of the Torah. Without it, mitzvot, reward and teshuvah would have no meaning.

"Choose life"

Before the Jewish people entered the Land of Israel, Moses told them: "I have set before you life and death, blessing and curse. Choose life" (Deuteronomy 30:19).

Maimonides writes that every person can become as righteous as Moses or as wicked as the worst king. No one forces a person to be good or bad. Each of us decides.

What is in our hands?

The Talmud says, "Everything is in the hands of Heaven except the fear of Heaven." In other words, G-d decides many things about our lives: our health, our circumstances, our talents and challenges. But how we respond, whether we choose to serve G-d and do good, is truly up to us.

This means free will is about moral and spiritual choices. We do not choose everything that happens to us. We choose who we become.

If G-d knows the future, are we free?

This is an ancient question. If G-d already knows what I will choose, how can my choice be free?

Maimonides answers that G-d's knowledge is not like human knowledge. G-d is beyond time, so His knowing does not cause our choices. We cannot fully understand how both are true, just as we cannot fully understand G-d. But both are true: G-d knows, and we choose.

The daily struggle

The Tanya teaches that each person has a G-dly soul and an animal soul, and they pull in different directions. Feelings and desires may arise on their own, and that is not a failure. What matters is what we do with them.

The Tanya gives a powerful tool: the mind can rule the heart. You may not control every feeling, but you can control:

  1. Thought: what you choose to dwell on.
  2. Speech: what you say.
  3. Action: what you do.

A person who always chooses well in these three areas, even while struggling inside, is called a beinoni. The Tanya teaches that this level is within reach of everyone.

Free will and teshuvah

Because we are free, we can also change. Teshuvah, returning to G-d, is possible at any moment. No past mistake takes away a person's power to choose good now.

Living with free will

In Lamorinda: Want to explore big questions like free will? Call Rabbi Labkowski at 925-384-7242 or see our adult education classes at jewishlamorinda.com/programs/adult-education.

Common questions

Does Judaism believe in fate?

Judaism teaches that G-d guides the world and many circumstances are set. But our moral choices are free, and prayer, tzedakah and teshuvah can change a person's path.

If I struggle with temptation, does it mean I am a bad person?

No. Struggle is part of being human. The Tanya teaches that a person who struggles and still chooses good brings great joy to G-d.

Are some people more free than others?

Everyone faces different challenges, and G-d judges each person according to their situation. But every person has the power to make the next right choice.

Step by step · Part 15 of 24

Life's big questions

NextWhy Do Bad Things Happen? A Jewish View of Suffering and FaithHow Judaism approaches suffering: Job, the limits of understanding, hidden good, crying out to G-d, and helping those in pain.

‹ Previous

All 24 parts
  1. Why Be Jewish? What Makes Jewish Life Worth Living
  2. What Does "the Chosen People" Mean in Judaism?
  3. Belief in G-d in Judaism: What Jews Believe About G-d
  4. Fear of G-d: What Yirat Shamayim Really Means
  5. How Can You Love G-d? The Mitzvah of Ahavat Hashem
  6. Doubts About G-d: A Jewish Approach to Questions of Faith
  7. What Do Jews Believe? Maimonides' 13 Principles of Faith
  8. Torah and Science: Can a Thinking Person Believe?
  9. Who Wrote the Torah? The Jewish Answer and Why It Matters
  10. Why Pray If G-d Already Knows What We Need?
  11. Does G-d Answer Prayers? A Jewish View of Yes, No and Not Yet
  12. The Soul in Judaism: What Is a Neshamah?
  13. Why Am I Here? The Jewish View of Life's Purpose
  14. Tikkun Olam: What "Repairing the World" Really Means in Judaism
  15. Free Will in Judaism: Do We Really Choose?
  16. Why Do Bad Things Happen? A Jewish View of Suffering and Faith
  17. The Book of Job: What It Teaches About Suffering
  18. Angry at G-d: A Jewish Answer for When It Hurts
  19. Hope in Hard Times: What Judaism Teaches About Not Giving Up
  20. Hashgacha Pratit: Divine Providence in Everyday Life
  21. Miracles: A Jewish View of the Wonders Big and Small
  22. The Afterlife in Judaism: What Happens After We Die?
  23. Moshiach: The Jewish Belief in the Messiah and the Messianic Era
  24. Techiyat HaMeitim: The Jewish Belief in the Resurrection of the Dead

See the whole series →

Questions about this, or something on your mind? Message the Rabbi or the Rebbetzin privately, or call 925-384-7242. · Email

Every week, free

Get the weekly email

Shabbat times, upcoming events, the Torah portion in two minutes, a guide to read, a mitzvah and a smile. Unsubscribe any time.