Learn › Jewish ideas › Big questions: purpose, suffering and the soul

Angry at G-d: A Jewish Answer for When It Hurts
Is it okay to be angry at G-d? Yes. How Jewish tradition welcomes your anger and pain, and how to bring it into prayer.
Part 18 of 24 · Life's big questions
On this page · 3 min read
Anger is a sign of relationship, not the end of itOur ancestors argued with G-dHow to bring your anger into prayerWhat the Rebbe taught about painKaddish: faith inside painYes, it is okay to be angry at G-d. Chassidic thought teaches that anger at G-d is permitted and can even be a sign of closeness, because people hold back their feelings from those they are distant from and speak openly to those they trust. If you are hurting, you are not a bad Jew, and you have not lost your place.
If you are in Lafayette, Moraga, Orinda or elsewhere in the East Bay and the pain is fresh, you can call Rabbi Yisroel Labkowski or Rebbetzin Tzipora Labkowski at 925-384-7242 and talk privately. You do not have to have it figured out.
Anger is a sign of relationship, not the end of it
A parent offers a helpful analogy. When a parent does something the children cannot understand, they protest. That protest is a sign that they care and that they believe the parent should have a good reason. People who are indifferent do not argue. Another answer, given to someone who asked this very question, says that G-d will be embracing you however you respond, and urges you to "stay engaged" and not walk away.
Also, simply saying "G-d must have His reasons" is not what the Jewish tradition expects from a devastated family. It is permissible, even important, to cry out.
Our ancestors argued with G-d
This is not new. In the Torah, Abraham challenges G-d over the fate of Sodom: "Shall the Judge of all the earth not do justice?" Moses, after things get worse for the Israelites in Egypt, asks G-d, "Why have You done evil to this people?" The prophets and the Psalms are full of protest and tears. The Torah did not hide these voices. It kept them.
If you want to read more about why suffering exists, see why bad things happen.
How to bring your anger into prayer
Prayer does not have to be polite. You can say what is in your heart in any language, in your own words, see talking to G-d in your own words.
- Say it out loud or write it down. "I am angry. I do not understand. This hurts."
- Say it to G-d, not only about G-d. A person cries out passionately only to someone with whom they are truly and intimately engaged.
- Ask a different question when you are ready. Try moving gradually from "Why did this happen?" to "What can I do now?" since the "why" may never be fully answered in this life.
- Do one small mitzvah. Light Shabbat candles, give charity, or say a Psalm. It does not have to feel inspiring.
What the Rebbe taught about pain
The Rebbe, Rabbi Menachem M. Schneerson, said he could not give a definitive reason for any specific tragedy. He taught that life has a before and an after, that the soul continues beyond death, and that pain may look senseless only because our view is limited. "Much more will be revealed in the Afterlife." This is not meant as a quick fix and it will not erase anyone's loss. It is an invitation to hold on to hope. See hope in hard times.
Kaddish: faith inside pain
Mourners say Kaddish, which praises G-d's greatness, even in their grief. Many describe this as saying "I am broken, and I am still here." That is faith standing next to anger. You are allowed to hold both.
In Lamorinda: If you are hurting and angry, you are welcome to talk privately with Rabbi Labkowski or Rebbetzin Labkowski: call 925-384-7242 or see /help/talk-to-the-rabbi.
Common questions
Is it okay to be angry at G-d in Judaism?
Yes. Chassidic teaching says that anger at G-d is permitted and can reflect a close relationship. Silence and walking away are what Judaism worries about, not honest anger.
Does being angry at G-d mean I do not believe?
No. You cannot be angry at someone you think is not there. Anger often shows that you are engaged.
Did anyone in the Torah argue with G-d?
Yes. Abraham pleaded for Sodom, and Moses asked why the Israelites suffered more after his first visit to Pharaoh.
What should I say to G-d when I am angry?
Say exactly what you feel, in your own words. You can also say Psalms (see Tehillim). There is no wrong way.
Why did G-d let this happen?
The Rebbe taught that no one can give a definite reason for a tragedy and that much will be revealed later. If this is your question after a loss, please talk privately with the Rabbi.
Can I still come to synagogue and the holidays if I am angry?
Yes, always. You are welcome as you are. See grief during the holidays.
Take the next step
- Talk to the Rabbi or the Rebbetzin, confidentially: talk to the Rabbi, or call 925-384-7242.
- Read why bad things happen and hope in hard times.
- See what is coming up at events, or call to hear what is planned.
Step by step · Part 18 of 24
Life's big questions
NextHope in Hard Times: What Judaism Teaches About Not Giving UpJewish hope and trust in G-d when life is hard: think good and it will be good, our people's story of hope, small daily steps, and asking for help.All 24 parts
- Why Be Jewish? What Makes Jewish Life Worth Living
- What Does "the Chosen People" Mean in Judaism?
- Belief in G-d in Judaism: What Jews Believe About G-d
- Fear of G-d: What Yirat Shamayim Really Means
- How Can You Love G-d? The Mitzvah of Ahavat Hashem
- Doubts About G-d: A Jewish Approach to Questions of Faith
- What Do Jews Believe? Maimonides' 13 Principles of Faith
- Torah and Science: Can a Thinking Person Believe?
- Who Wrote the Torah? The Jewish Answer and Why It Matters
- Why Pray If G-d Already Knows What We Need?
- Does G-d Answer Prayers? A Jewish View of Yes, No and Not Yet
- The Soul in Judaism: What Is a Neshamah?
- Why Am I Here? The Jewish View of Life's Purpose
- Tikkun Olam: What "Repairing the World" Really Means in Judaism
- Free Will in Judaism: Do We Really Choose?
- Why Do Bad Things Happen? A Jewish View of Suffering and Faith
- The Book of Job: What It Teaches About Suffering
- Angry at G-d: A Jewish Answer for When It Hurts
- Hope in Hard Times: What Judaism Teaches About Not Giving Up
- Hashgacha Pratit: Divine Providence in Everyday Life
- Miracles: A Jewish View of the Wonders Big and Small
- The Afterlife in Judaism: What Happens After We Die?
- Moshiach: The Jewish Belief in the Messiah and the Messianic Era
- Techiyat HaMeitim: The Jewish Belief in the Resurrection of the Dead
Questions about this, or something on your mind? Message the Rabbi or the Rebbetzin privately, or call 925-384-7242. · Email
Read next
Why Do Bad Things Happen? A Jewish View of Suffering and FaithHow Judaism approaches suffering: Job, the limits of understanding, hidden good, crying out to G-d, and helping those in pain.Read next →