Learn › Jewish ideas › Tanya: your inner life

The Two Souls Explained: Tanya on the Divine Soul and the Animal Soul
What are the two souls in Tanya? Why you can feel torn: the divine soul and the animal soul explained simply, and who is in charge.
On this page · 3 min read
Why do I feel torn?The animal soulThe divine soulWho is in charge?What this looks like in an ordinary dayA noteAccording to the Tanya, every Jew has two souls: a divine soul, "a part of G-d above," that longs for goodness and closeness to G-d, and an animal soul, the natural self, with its drives and desires. The feeling of being torn between them is normal, and the Tanya says the choice of who leads is yours.
This is the central idea of the book. If you have ever wondered why you want to do the right thing and also want something else, this is Tanya's answer.
Why do I feel torn?
Chapter 1 of the Tanya says that every Jew has two souls (see Tanya Chapter 1 explained). The first, the animal soul, gives life to the body. The second, described in Chapter 2, is a true part of G-d.
So the inner argument is not a sign that something is wrong with you. Chassidic teaching puts it this way: G-d did not create people to be perfect; striving is the point. For the general Jewish view of the inner struggle, see the yetzer hara.
The animal soul
The animal soul is the natural self: it wants comfort, pleasure and recognition. Chapter 1 lists the pulls it can bring: anger and pride, the love of pleasure, frivolity and idle talk, laziness and gloom. Yet the same chapter says the Jewish animal soul also has good natural traits, like compassion and kindness. Read more in is the animal soul bad?.
The divine soul
The divine soul is what the Tanya calls a part of G-d. Chapter 4 says that its intellect (chochmah, binah and daat) and its emotions (love and fear of G-d) find expression through thought, speech and action. Read more in a part of G-d above.
Who is in charge?
Chapter 12 explains that in the beinoni, the ordinary person who strives, the divine soul directs thought, speech and action, while the animal soul still stirs desires in the heart. He does not let them rule him, even for a moment. Put simply, a person copes, even if he does not "triumph," and keeps striving. See the beinoni and mind over heart.
A helpful image: climbing a steep hill on a bicycle, you will sometimes falter, and what matters is to keep pedaling.
What this looks like in an ordinary day
These are our own examples of the two voices, not quotations from the Tanya:
- the alarm rings, and one voice says "five more minutes" while another says "get up and learn";
- an annoying message arrives, and one voice wants to reply at once while another says "wait";
- there is an extra treat on the plate, and you ask what you really want.
In each case, you can choose which voice leads.
A note
The Tanya's guidance is spiritual. It is not a replacement for medical or psychological help. If your inner struggle feels like more than ordinary temptation, such as deep sadness or anxiety, speak with a professional as well, and ask the Rabbi.
In Lamorinda: Feel pulled in two directions? Come to the Wednesday 1:00 PM Tanya class in Lafayette, or call Rabbi Labkowski at 925-384-7242.
Common questions
What are the two souls in Tanya?
The divine soul (nefesh Elokit) and the animal soul (nefesh habahamit). Both are in every Jew.
Why do I feel torn between right and wrong in Judaism?
Tanya explains it as the two souls pulling in different directions. Feeling the pull is normal and is not a failure.
Is the animal soul evil?
No. Chapter 1 says it has good natural traits such as compassion and kindness, and Tanya teaches that it can be raised up through a mitzvah. See is the animal soul bad?.
Which soul is the real me?
Both are in you. Chapter 2 says the divine soul is truly a part of G-d, and Chapter 12 describes the beinoni, who lets it lead in thought, speech and action.
Do I need to be very observant to learn about the two souls?
No. The Tanya was written for ordinary people who struggle, and every Jew is welcome to learn it. Call Rabbi Labkowski at 925-384-7242 to ask about learning together.
Where can I learn about the two souls in Lafayette, Moraga or Orinda?
At the Tanya class in English, every Wednesday at 1:00 PM at the Rabbi's home in Lafayette. Call 925-384-7242 for the address.
Take the next step
- Read is the animal soul bad?.
- Read a part of G-d above.
- Come to the Wednesday 1:00 PM class, or call Rabbi Labkowski at 925-384-7242.
Questions about this, or something on your mind? Message the Rabbi or the Rebbetzin privately, or call 925-384-7242. · Email
Read next
Is the Animal Soul Bad? Tanya on Your Natural SelfIs the animal soul evil? Tanya says it has good traits and can be raised up. Learn how your drive and energy can serve something higher.Read next →