5th of Kislev, 5787 · Shabbat candles Fri, Nov 20 4:35 PM · Parashat Vayetzei
Chabad of Lamorinda

Learn › Jewish ideas › G-d, faith and holiness

Does G-d Answer Prayers? A Jewish View of Yes, No and Not Yet

Does G-d answer prayers? Chabad teaches that every sincere prayer is answered, though the answer can be hidden or late. Read this honest guide.

Part 11 of 24 · Life's big questions

On this page · 3 min readWhy pray if G-d already knows what we need?"Every prayer is answered": what it meansWhen the answer is not what we prayed forWhat to do while we wait

According to Chabad teaching, G-d hears every sincere prayer, and every prayer is answered. But the answer does not always look the way we hoped, and it may come later or wrapped in a way we cannot yet recognize. This is a big question, and it is often asked in pain. This guide gives the Chabad answer honestly, and also what we do while we wait.

Why pray if G-d already knows what we need?

Jewish tradition asks this question directly. G-d knows what we need, so why ask? The answer is that prayer helps us recognize that everything we have comes from G-d. When we need something, turning to G-d is the natural response. Praying also changes the person who prays: it asks us to stop and think about what we really want and where it comes from. For the basics, see Why Pray?.

"Every prayer is answered": what it means

The Baal Shem Tov, founder of Chassidism, taught that every prayer is answered, but the answer may differ from what we expect, and it may come later. This is often quoted, and Chassidic teaching also explains it more deeply.

Tzvi Freeman, writing from a discourse of the Lubavitcher Rebbe, says that when a person sets ego aside in prayer, that brings delight above, and that delight returns below as a blessing. He explains that the answer comes in this world, not only in some spiritual realm, because people pray for real needs in the real world. Why then does it so often seem that nothing happened? Because the answer is "packaged" in the coarse, messy realities of this world, and we often cannot see through the wrapping to recognize it. He adds that a time will come when the wrapping falls away and the answers will be seen.

When the answer is not what we prayed for

Freeman also wrestles honestly with this question. He rejects the idea that G-d simply answers "no" to so many sincere requests, asking whether a loving parent would do so. He also admits that human beings cannot fully understand certain tragedies, and he quotes the verse "How deep are Your thoughts" (Psalms 92:6). At the same time he cautions that understanding can make us passive. Instead of resigning ourselves, he writes, we should be outraged by evil and work to fill the world with light.

If you have prayed for someone who did not recover, this does not erase your pain, and no guide can explain it. It is all right to ask, to cry and even to be angry. See Angry at G-d and Hope in hard times. For your own situation, talk privately with the Rabbi.

What to do while we wait

In Lamorinda: If you are praying for someone or struggling with this question, talk privately with the Rabbi: /help/talk-to-the-rabbi or 925-384-7242.

Common questions

Does G-d answer prayers in Judaism?

Yes. Chabad teaches, in the name of the Baal Shem Tov, that every prayer is answered, though the answer may differ from what we expected and may come later.

Why does it seem that G-d does not answer my prayers?

According to a discourse of the Lubavitcher Rebbe, the answer is "packaged" in the messy realities of the world, so it is often hard to recognize at the time.

Does G-d ever say no?

Some teachers explain that sometimes the answer is "no" or "not yet." Tzvi Freeman, writing about the Rebbe's teaching, finds it hard to believe that a loving G-d would turn away so many sincere prayers, and teaches from the Rebbe that every prayer is answered in this world, even when the answer is hidden. No one can fully explain why a particular prayer seemed to go unanswered, so please talk to the Rabbi about your own situation.

Is it all right to be angry at G-d?

Jewish tradition allows honest questions and even protest, and many have prayed in tears. See Angry at G-d.

Why pray if G-d already knows what I need?

Prayer helps us recognize that everything comes from G-d, and turning to Him in need is the natural response.

Can I get help with praying in Lafayette, Moraga or Orinda?

Yes. Rabbi Labkowski at Chabad of Lamorinda in Lafayette is glad to help. Call 925-384-7242 or add a name to the Tehillim prayer list.

Take the next step

Step by step · Part 11 of 24

Life's big questions

NextThe Soul in Judaism: What Is a Neshamah?What Judaism teaches about the soul, the five levels of the soul, the G-dly and animal souls, and the purpose of the soul's journey in this world.

‹ Previous

All 24 parts
  1. Why Be Jewish? What Makes Jewish Life Worth Living
  2. What Does "the Chosen People" Mean in Judaism?
  3. Belief in G-d in Judaism: What Jews Believe About G-d
  4. Fear of G-d: What Yirat Shamayim Really Means
  5. How Can You Love G-d? The Mitzvah of Ahavat Hashem
  6. Doubts About G-d: A Jewish Approach to Questions of Faith
  7. What Do Jews Believe? Maimonides' 13 Principles of Faith
  8. Torah and Science: Can a Thinking Person Believe?
  9. Who Wrote the Torah? The Jewish Answer and Why It Matters
  10. Why Pray If G-d Already Knows What We Need?
  11. Does G-d Answer Prayers? A Jewish View of Yes, No and Not Yet
  12. The Soul in Judaism: What Is a Neshamah?
  13. Why Am I Here? The Jewish View of Life's Purpose
  14. Tikkun Olam: What "Repairing the World" Really Means in Judaism
  15. Free Will in Judaism: Do We Really Choose?
  16. Why Do Bad Things Happen? A Jewish View of Suffering and Faith
  17. The Book of Job: What It Teaches About Suffering
  18. Angry at G-d: A Jewish Answer for When It Hurts
  19. Hope in Hard Times: What Judaism Teaches About Not Giving Up
  20. Hashgacha Pratit: Divine Providence in Everyday Life
  21. Miracles: A Jewish View of the Wonders Big and Small
  22. The Afterlife in Judaism: What Happens After We Die?
  23. Moshiach: The Jewish Belief in the Messiah and the Messianic Era
  24. Techiyat HaMeitim: The Jewish Belief in the Resurrection of the Dead

See the whole series →

Questions about this, or something on your mind? Message the Rabbi or the Rebbetzin privately, or call 925-384-7242. · Email

Every week, free

Get the weekly email

Shabbat times, upcoming events, the Torah portion in two minutes, a guide to read, a mitzvah and a smile. Unsubscribe any time.