5th of Kislev, 5787 · Shabbat candles Fri, Nov 20 4:35 PM · Parashat Vayetzei
Chabad of Lamorinda

Stories and jokes › Parables and teaching tales

The Milkman and the Baker

Early one morning, a milkman was bewildered to find a court summons hanging on his door. He was an honest man and had always behaved as one. He never cheated, lied or stole. He had no idea why he had been summoned to court.

But the baker knew. The baker used to buy butter and cheese from the milkman for his business. One day he began to suspect that the lumps of butter the milkman sold him weighed less than five pounds, even though the milkman insisted that each was exactly five pounds. The baker decided to look into it, and for a while he weighed every lump of butter he bought from the milkman. He found that they were indeed less than five pounds. Sometimes four pounds, sometimes four and a half, and once even three. The baker was angry. "He's cheating me!" he told his wife. "I am not going to keep quiet about it."

He went to the local court and complained about the milkman. "We have to prosecute him," said the baker. "We can't let him cheat all the villagers. People trust this crook!" Later that day, the court messenger hung a notice on the milkman's house summoning him to court.

The milkman arrived at the courthouse shaking with fear. He had never been to a court and had never spoken to a judge, and the judge was a man the villagers feared.

"I assume you have a very accurate scale in your dairy," the judge said to the milkman.

"No, Your Honor, I do not have a scale," said the milkman.

"So how do you weigh the butter? Do you just guess?"

"No, G-d forbid, Your Honor. I am an honest man; it would never occur to me to do something like that. Very simply, I built myself a scale, the kind that needs a weight on one side to balance the butter on the other."

The judge nodded, and the milkman continued. "Every morning, when I come to weigh the butter for the baker, I place the five-pound loaf of bread he gives me on one side of the scale. That way I know that the butter I give the baker will be exactly five pounds."

"So," said the judge, "you're telling us that the butter you give the baker weighs exactly as much as the loaf of bread he supplies to you?"

"That is exactly it!" exclaimed the milkman.

The baker's face fell. You see, the baker's own scale was dishonest. The five pounds of bread he weighed out each morning for the milkman were not truly five pounds, and that is exactly what came back to him.

How true this is of many of us. We judge people based on who we are, and what we put out to people is what comes back to us. In life, we end up eating the cake we ourselves have baked.

Source: A parable, from Rabbi Labkowski's story collection

More parables and teaching tales

Read more about it

All the stories and jokes

Every week, free

Get the weekly email

Shabbat times, upcoming events, the Torah portion in two minutes, a guide to read, a mitzvah and a smile. Unsubscribe any time.