Learn › Jewish ideas › Big questions: purpose, suffering and the soul

Tanya in Hard Times: Finding Strength When Life Hurts
What the Tanya says to someone who is suffering: hidden good, joy as strength, and why asking for help is right. Gentle Jewish wisdom.
On this page · 3 min read
First, a word of honestyHidden good: what Epistle 11 and Chapter 26 teachWhat Tanya offers when we cannot feel any of thisSmall steps for hard daysThe Tanya does not tell a suffering person to smile. It offers a different strength: the idea that G-d is present even in pain, and that what hurts may hold a good that is hidden from us for now. This guide is an invitation to that wisdom, never a demand.
First, a word of honesty
If you are going through illness, a lost job, a broken marriage or any real pain, nobody should tell you to "just be happy." Crying is human. Asking for help, from a doctor, a counselor, friends or the Rabbi, is right and good. See angry at G-d for the Jewish view that your anger and pain are welcome in prayer.
Tanya's guidance is spiritual. It sits beside professional help, not in place of it.
Hidden good: what Epistle 11 and Chapter 26 teach
The Tanya was written by Rabbi Shneur Zalman of Liadi, the Alter Rebbe, founder of Chabad. Two places in it speak directly to hard times. We tell them in our own words.
Epistle 11 (Iggeret HaKodesh). The Alter Rebbe writes that nothing evil comes down from Above. Everything is good, but sometimes its goodness is too lofty for us to see, and the good can be "clothed" in pain until it is revealed. This is the idea in Tanya on worry and trust.
Chapter 26. Chapter 26 says that just as one blesses G-d for good, one should accept hardship with joy. It explains that hardship seems negative because it comes from a hidden level of G-dliness, higher than the open good we usually recognize. The chapter says those who love G-d, and value closeness to Him above comfort, can find joy even in suffering.
These are big ideas. Few people feel them in the middle of a crisis, and the Tanya does not say you must.
What Tanya offers when we cannot feel any of this
Here is what the same pages give us, in simple terms.
- Strength from joy. Chapter 26 compares the inner struggle to wrestling. A strong person who is sluggish still loses. Energy and an open heart win. Joy here means inner life and energy, not a forced smile.
- Fixed time for sadness, then release. The chapter says real sadness over one's mistakes has its place, at specific, suitable times, and then one should let it go and trust G-d's forgiveness. It is not meant to follow you through every hour.
- A purpose in the struggle. The chapter says those who accept hardship with love will see its hidden good revealed in the World to Come.
- You are not alone. Your soul, in Tanya's words, is "a part of G-d above" (see the soul). Even in the dark, that connection is not broken.
Small steps for hard days
These are suggestions in the spirit of the text, not quotations from it.
- Let yourself say it out loud, to G-d in your own words and to a person.
- Do one small mitzvah today: give a coin to tzedakah, light Shabbat candles, say Modeh Ani.
- Ask for help, practically and without shame. See hope in hard times.
- Remember that why bad things happen is a question Judaism has always asked, openly.
In Lamorinda: Going through something hard? Call Rabbi Labkowski at 925-384-7242 or visit /help/talk-to-the-rabbi. You do not have to face it alone.
Common questions
What does the Tanya say about suffering?
The Tanya teaches that nothing truly evil comes from Above, that apparent suffering holds a hidden good, and that we should serve G-d with joy. It also offers strength, not guilt. For a personal situation, ask the Rabbi.
Does Tanya say I have to be happy when things are bad?
No. The Tanya invites us toward joy as a source of strength, and describes a high ideal, but nothing in it says that crying or asking for help is wrong. Be gentle with yourself.
Is sadness a sin in Judaism?
Sadness is human. The Tanya says real sadness has a time and place, such as remorse over one's mistakes at set times, and that we should not let heaviness take over our whole day. If sadness is heavy or lasting, professional help is also the right step.
Where can I find comfort in Jewish tradition when I am struggling?
Read hope in hard times, say Psalms (Tehillim), and talk with someone. In Lafayette, Moraga and Orinda you can call Rabbi Labkowski at 925-384-7242.
Is this the same as saying "everything happens for a reason"?
Not quite. The Tanya says the good may be hidden, and it never tells a suffering person that their pain is small. It asks us to hold faith and to keep acting kindly and asking for help.
Is there a Tanya class where I can learn more?
Yes, there is a Tanya class in English every Wednesday at 1:00 PM, until 2:00 PM, at the Rabbi's home in Lafayette. Call 925-384-7242 for the address.
Take the next step
- Read Tanya on worry and trust.
- Read Feeling not good enough? on your worth in Tanya.
- Call the Rabbi at 925-384-7242, or ask for help if you or a family member need support.
Questions about this, or something on your mind? Message the Rabbi or the Rebbetzin privately, or call 925-384-7242. · Email
Read next
How to Stop Worrying: Tanya on Trust in G-d (Iggeret HaKodesh 11)How to stop worrying, Jewish view: the Tanya's Epistle 11 on hidden good and trust in G-d, a true story, and the Wednesday Tanya class in Lafayette.Read next →