Learn › Jewish ideas › Tzedakah: how and why to give

Giving Anonymously: The Jewish Value of Quiet Generosity
Is it better to give charity anonymously? What Maimonides' levels of tzedakah teach about secret giving, dignity and humility, and how to give quietly.
On this page · 3 min read
Why anonymity mattersThe levels that deal with secrecyAnonymous giving and humilityHow to give quietly todayIs it wrong to be named?In Jewish teaching, giving charity anonymously is one of the highest ways to give, because it protects the dignity of the person who receives. In Maimonides' ranking of the eight levels of tzedakah, the second-highest level is when neither the giver nor the receiver knows the other's name.
Why anonymity matters
Tzedakah (צְדָקָה) means "justice" or "righteousness." No one should have to pay with his or her dignity to receive help. When a gift is given quietly, the receiver does not feel small or indebted, and the giver does not feel big. That protects both.
Maimonides' "Eight Degrees of Giving" reflect this: when the receiver knows the giver, the receiver may feel ashamed, and when the giver knows the receiver, the giver may feel a sense of superiority. Mutual anonymity removes both feelings, so no one is placed above or below anyone else.
The levels that deal with secrecy
Maimonides (the Rambam) lists eight levels of giving. Listing from the top, these are the ones about who knows whom:
- Level 2: nobody knows. You give to the poor without knowing who receives it, and the receiver does not know the giver. This level recalls the anonymous fund in the Temple. A charity fund can work the same way, if the one running it is trustworthy and capable.
- Level 3: the giver knows, the receiver does not. You know whom you are helping, but they do not know who helped them. The Sages would quietly leave coins at the doors of the poor.
- Level 4: the receiver knows, the giver does not. You do not know who receives your gift, but the poor person knows you gave it. Some Sages would toss coins behind their backs so the poor could pick them up without shame.
Above all of them, Maimonides places helping someone stand on their own. See The Highest Tzedakah. For the full list and for who to give to first, see Tzedakah Priorities.
Anonymous giving and humility
Quiet giving also guards the giver. When no one will know, the gift is about the person in need and not about our name. That is why anonymous giving fits so well with humility.
How to give quietly today
The Jewish way of giving is to give anonymously when possible, give before you are asked, and give warmly, with a smile. A few ways this can look:
- Give through a trusted charity or fund rather than directly to someone you know.
- Put a coin in the pushka and let the box do the work. (See The Pushka.)
- Ask for your gift to be anonymous. Many charities can do this if you ask.
- Keep it to yourself. You do not need to tell friends or family about every gift.
Is it wrong to be named?
Not necessarily. Maimonides ranks anonymity as a higher level, but the lowest level is giving unwillingly, not giving openly. Many institutions thank their donors, and the choice to be named or not is personal. If you are unsure, ask the Rabbi. At Chabad of Lamorinda, the Chai Club honor board shows only the donors who choose to be shown.
In Lamorinda: Want to talk about how to give in a way that fits you? Call Rabbi Labkowski at 925-384-7242.
Common questions
Is it better to give charity anonymously in Judaism?
Yes, anonymity is considered a higher level of giving, because it protects the receiver's dignity and the giver's humility. In Maimonides' list, the second-highest level is giving where neither side knows the other.
What are the eight levels of tzedakah?
They range from giving unwillingly (the lowest) up to helping someone become self-sufficient (the highest). Maimonides lists them, and Tzedakah Priorities explains them.
Can a gift be anonymous if I give to a charity that sends receipts?
Ask the charity how it handles names. Many charities can keep your gift off any public list. For tax questions, ask your tax advisor.
Is it wrong to want a plaque or public thanks?
Maimonides' list does not forbid it; it ranks quiet giving higher. A name can also inspire others. Ask the Rabbi what fits your situation.
Should I give anonymously to a person I know?
That is Level 3 in Maimonides' list: you know whom you help, but they do not know it was you. It is ranked high because the person keeps their dignity.
How can I teach children to give quietly?
Let them drop coins in the pushka and do kind things without announcing them. See Children, Money and Tzedakah.
Take the next step
- Choose one gift this week that nobody but you will know about.
- Read The Highest Tzedakah to see what ranks above even anonymous giving.
- To give or to ask where help is needed in Lafayette, Moraga and Orinda, call Rabbi Labkowski at 925-384-7242 or visit Giving.
Questions about this, or something on your mind? Message the Rabbi or the Rebbetzin privately, or call 925-384-7242. · Email
Read next
Tzedakah Priorities: Who to Give to FirstJewish law's order of giving: family, your own community, the poor of your city, Israel. Giving with dignity, Rambam's eight levels, and giving to all.Read next →