5th of Kislev, 5787 · Shabbat candles Fri, Nov 20 4:35 PM · Parashat Vayetzei
Chabad of Lamorinda

Stories and jokes › Stories of the Rebbe

The Rich Miser of Krakow

Rabbi Dovid Schochet of Toronto once received an invitation from an organization in Buffalo, New York, to speak on the topic of charity before a crowd of university students, most of them not Jewish, among them priests. He had his reservations. On the one hand he wanted to educate; on the other he wanted to avoid interfaith debates. So he called the office of the Lubavitcher Rebbe and asked one of the secretaries to put the question to the Rebbe.

The answer came immediately: the Rebbe said he should accept, and should be sure to end his lecture with the story of the rich miser of Krakow.

Rabbi Schochet threw himself into the task (though the Rebbe's insistence on that particular story seemed a little unusual). When the date arrived he flew to Buffalo and gave a fascinating two-hour talk on the uniqueness of the Torah's approach to tzedakah. Just as the crowd was about to applaud, he announced that he wanted to tell one more story.

Almost four hundred years ago, in the city of Krakow, there lived a rich Jew named Yisroel. No one really knew his last name, and no one cared, because he was a miserable person. He lived in a large, plush home and was very wealthy, but he was a hard-hearted miser and everyone avoided him. If an unsuspecting charity collector knocked on his door, he received an abrupt "No money!" and a door slammed in his face.

Although it is forbidden to call people derogatory names, this old man was so stingy that eventually everyone began calling him "Yisroel Goy," saying that only a non-Jew could be so callous toward other Jews. Unfortunately, the name stuck.

So it went on for many years. In fact, everyone had completely forgotten about the old skinflint, until one day the burial society, the Chevra Kadisha, received a message to come to his bedside. "Here is two thousand dollars," he announced. "You're not going to get another penny from me, so don't ask. I want you to bury me in a good spot, not near the fence or the garbage dump, and write on my tombstone: Yisroel Goy." He then said the Shema, closed his eyes, and a few days later passed away.

No one knew exactly how old he was, maybe ninety, maybe more, but one thing was certain: no one wept at his funeral. In fact, almost no one attended, and they didn't bury him exactly where he had asked. But they did write what he wanted on his tombstone: YISROEL GOY.

That was the end of a sad episode in the history of Krakow. Or so they thought.

One afternoon about a week later, the Rav of the city, Rabbi Yom-Tov Lipman Heller, heard a knock on his door. When he opened it, about fifty hungry faces greeted him.

"Yes, can I help you?" he asked, astonished. "Where are you all from?"

"We are from here, from Krakow," one of them cried out, "and we are hungry. We haven't eaten anything all day."

The Rav didn't understand what was going on, but he invited them all in and found them places to sit, and while his wife prepared something for them to eat, he heard their story. For as long as they could remember, these poor people had been going to the grocery store every day and taking what they needed. They only had to sign, and that was it. But since yesterday, the grocer refused to give them anything, and so they were all hungry.

"Very strange," the Rav thought to himself. "So many hungry people, and all from here, from Krakow! Could they be lying? I must get to the bottom of this." He waited for them to finish eating and told them to come back tomorrow morning.

Then he put on his overcoat, told his wife he would return shortly, and walked toward the home of the town treasurer. From far away he could see a crowd gathered at that door too, and as he approached he could hear the treasurer trying to make some order of the chaos.

"Oy! Am I glad you are here!" the treasurer shouted when he saw the Rav. "Look inside, my house is full too. There must be three hundred people here, and this is the second shift. A big group just left!"

"I know," the Rav answered. "They came to me also, different people, but hungry, and all of them say they are from Krakow. I simply don't understand it." After everyone had been fed and the treasurer had handed out some money for tomorrow's meals, the two of them walked to the house of the grocer.

"Sure," the grocer said, "I used to give everyone food. They would sign, and at the end of each week I'd give the bill to that rich old man who just died, the one they called Yisroel Goy. It's been going on for, I'd say, forty years, maybe more, even before I owned the store. He was my best customer, that old man. But he kept warning me not to tell anyone, not even my wife. Every time he paid he said that if he heard people knew he was paying, he'd stop."

The Rav summoned the whole town to the cemetery. Every eye was on him as he stepped from the crowd, stood at the foot of the grave, and began to speak.

"Yisroel, Yisroel! We've come here today to say we are sorry." He paused; the silence was broken by muffled weeping from the crowd. "I know you don't need our apologies, but we are sorry. We're sorry that we were so cruel, crueler than we accused you of being. And we're sorry that no one was your friend and that no one really cared."

Now the cries were louder; almost everyone was sobbing. The Rav waited for silence, dried his eyes and continued. "I know you wanted the words 'Yisroel Goy' written on your tombstone. Well, I've done something that I hope you won't mind. I had the stonecutter add a word." With this, the Rav pulled away the cloth, and in place of "Yisroel Goy" the inscription now read: YISROEL GOY KADOSH: Yisroel, the holy "goy."

Rabbi Schochet finished his lecture, and the crowd showed its appreciation with rounds of applause.

After he had finished shaking hands and was making his way out, a young priest approached him and asked if it was possible to speak with him alone. There was something strangely sincere in the young man's eyes, and Rabbi Schochet set an appointment for the next afternoon in his hotel room. The young man came at the time they had set, sat down, and asked the rabbi to repeat the story he had told, and then to explain several points. He listened deeply to the answers, and when they finished they shook hands and parted.

Years later Rabbi Schochet, on a visit to Israel, was praying at the Kotel when a young, bearded Breslover chassid approached him and shook his hand warmly. "Do you recognize me?" he asked. "I am the priest who visited you years ago in your hotel room." Rabbi Schochet stared at him, so astounded he couldn't speak.

"You don't know what that story you told about the miser did to me," the young man continued. "You see, my mother was Jewish, but she kept it a secret. She escaped from Poland to America during the war, and there she married a devout Catholic. It wasn't so easy being a Jew in those times. Just before she died, she told me that same story, and added that we are Jews, and that the holy, generous Jew who supported hundreds of people anonymously in Krakow hundreds of years ago was my great-grandfather. Your story woke something that was sleeping in my soul, and now I've returned to myself."

It took several years, but Rabbi Schochet now understood why the Lubavitcher Rebbe had insisted on that particular story.

Source: JEM 'Here's My Story: A Confluence of Souls' (Rabbi Dovid Schochet, Toronto), reprinted on CrownHeights.info; the Krakow legend itself on Chabad.org 'Israel Goy'

More stories of the rebbe

Read more about it

All the stories and jokes

Every week, free

Get the weekly email

Shabbat times, upcoming events, the Torah portion in two minutes, a guide to read, a mitzvah and a smile. Unsubscribe any time.