Stories and jokes › Parables and teaching tales
The Cost of Lying
A poor Jew found a wallet with $700 in it. At his synagogue he read a notice: a wealthy congregant had lost his wallet and was offering a $100 reward. He spotted the owner and handed him the wallet.
The rich man counted the money and said, "I see you already took your reward."
"What?" said the poor man.
"This wallet had $800 in it when I lost it."
They began to argue, and in the end they came before the rabbi. Each stated his case. The rich man finished by saying, "Rabbi, I trust you believe me."
"Of course," said the rabbi, and the rich man smiled. The poor man was crushed.
Then the rabbi handed the wallet to the poor man.
"What are you doing?!" yelled the rich man.
"You are, of course, an honest man," the rabbi answered, "and you say the wallet you lost had $800 in it. So I am sure it did. But if the man who found this wallet were a liar and a thief, he would not have returned it at all. Which means this wallet must belong to somebody else. If that person steps forward, he will get the money. Until then, it belongs to the man who found it."
"And what about my money?" asked the rich man.
"Well, we will just have to wait until somebody finds a wallet with $800 in it."
Source: A parable, from Rabbi Labkowski's story collection
More parables and teaching tales
- Paid in Full With One Glass of Milk
- Ben-Gurion and the Mayflower
- The Milkman and the Baker
- A Thousand Marbles
Read more about it
Honesty and Truth: Emet in Jewish LifeWhy truth is G-d's seal, keeping your word, when Judaism allows a small change for peace, honesty in business and with children, and admitting mistakes.
Money and Success: A Jewish View of WealthWhat Judaism teaches about earning, spending and giving: wealth as a trust from G-d, honest business, tzedakah and maaser, contentment, and teaching kids about money.