Learn › Jewish ideas › Tanya: your inner life

Why Do I Still Struggle? Tanya on the Inner Battle That Never Ends
Still struggling with the same temptations? Tanya says the struggle is normal and may be the very purpose, and never a sign you are a fraud. Learn why.
Part 34 of 34 · Growing as a person
On this page · 3 min read
"I thought I would be over this by now"The struggle may be the pointYou do not have to feel itHonest, but not harshA word of careYes, it is normal to keep struggling, and Tanya says the struggle is not a sign that something is wrong with you. In Chapter 27, Rabbi Shneur Zalman of Liadi teaches that a person should not be deeply discouraged even if the battle with his inner pull lasts a lifetime, since this struggle may be exactly what he was created for.
If you feel like a hypocrite because you pray, keep Shabbat or give charity and still feel pulled in the wrong direction, this guide is for you.
"I thought I would be over this by now"
Many people expect that sincere effort will make temptation disappear. Then, years later, the same impulse returns, and they think, "I must be fake."
Tanya sees it differently. According to Chapter 12 of the Tanya, even the beinoni (see the beinoni) has an animal soul that is still active and still stirs up desires, especially after prayer, when the closeness of prayer fades. The difference is what he does with them. He does not act on them. The struggle remains, and so does his choice.
The struggle may be the point
Chapter 27 goes further. It says that being somewhat troubled by wrong thoughts is right, since complete indifference would end the struggle, but deep depression is not. The chapter reads the words "You have created wicked men" to mean that people are created so that wrong thoughts come to them, not so that they actually act wickedly. Only tzaddikim fully remove the evil from within.
It also describes two kinds of Divine pleasure: the first when darkness is completely turned into light, as tzaddikim do, and the second when the negative force is subdued while it is still at full strength, as beinonim do. The chapter compares them to sweet foods and to sharp or sour foods that are spiced until they become delicious. In this picture, your effort is not a failure to be perfect; it is its own kind of gift.
You do not have to feel it
Chapter 14 adds relief. The rank of beinoni, it says, is open to every person "at any time or hour," and it does not depend on feeling. A person may not yet hate evil in his heart, because feelings change with the day. What is in our control is choice: to turn away from evil and do good in action, speech and thought. So the person who struggles, and keeps choosing, is doing exactly what Tanya asks.
Honest, but not harsh
None of this excuses carelessness. Chapter 30 teaches that we should honestly measure our own effort against the struggle another person might be facing, and not judge others until we are in their place. See Tanya on humility. When we do fall, teshuvah is always open, and success and failure looks at how a fall can become a step forward.
A word of care
Tanya speaks about a spiritual struggle. If your struggle involves addiction, constant hopelessness or thoughts of harming yourself, please get professional help right away; that is also what Jewish tradition asks of us. See addiction and recovery. For a personal situation, ask the Rabbi.
In Lamorinda: Come to the English Tanya class every Wednesday at 1:00 PM at the Rabbi's home in Lafayette; call Rabbi Labkowski at 925-384-7242 for the address.
Common questions
Is it normal to struggle with the same sin again and again?
Yes. Tanya says the inner struggle may last a lifetime, and that one should not be deeply discouraged. Falling does not cancel the effort; teshuvah is always possible.
Does struggling mean I am a hypocrite?
No. Tanya's beinoni feels the pull and does not act on it. Feeling a wrong desire is not hypocrisy; choosing right while feeling it is the point.
Why doesn't G-d just remove my temptation?
Chapter 27 suggests that the struggle may be exactly what a person was created for. Only tzaddikim fully remove the evil within, and the beinoni's battle has its own value.
Do I have to feel spiritual to be on the right path?
No. Chapter 14 says the beinoni level does not depend on feeling, but on choosing in action, speech and thought.
What if I feel hopeless about changing?
Tanya's guidance is spiritual, and professional help is also right when needed. Ask the Rabbi, and see changing a bad habit.
Take the next step
- Read next: how to resist temptation and unwanted thoughts.
- Join the English Tanya class on Wednesdays at 1:00 PM at the Rabbi's home in Lafayette, a good place for questions from Lafayette, Moraga and Orinda. Call 925-384-7242 for the address.
- For a private conversation, talk to the Rabbi.
Step by step · Part 34 of 34
Growing as a person
You have reached the end of this series.
All 34 parts
- Humility: What Being Humble Really Means in Judaism
- Tanya on Humility: Chapter 30 and Not Judging Others
- Self-Esteem in Judaism: A Jewish View of Self-Worth and Humility
- Feeling Not Good Enough? What Tanya Says About Your Worth
- Judging Others Favorably: The Jewish Art of the Benefit of the Doubt
- Ahavat Yisrael: How to Love Every Jew Like Yourself
- What Is a Mensch? How to Be a Mensch with Everyday Jewish Decency
- Derech Eretz: Jewish Manners and Common Decency
- Anger: Jewish Wisdom for Calming Down and Making Things Right
- What Does Tanya Say About Anger? The Letter on Anger (Epistle 25)
- Patience: Jewish Wisdom for Waiting, Raising Kids and Living With Others
- Jealousy and Envy: Jewish Wisdom for When You Compare Yourself
- Being Happy With What You Have: The Jewish Secret of Contentment
- Anxiety and Worry: Jewish Wisdom for Finding Calm
- How to Stop Worrying: Tanya on Trust in G-d (Iggeret HaKodesh 11)
- Hakarat Hatov: Gratitude in Judaism
- Tanya on Gratitude: Seeing G-d's Kindness Every Moment
- Simcha: Happiness and Joy in Judaism
- What Does Tanya Say About Sadness? Staying Joyful in Chapters 26-27
- Honesty and Truth: Emet in Jewish Life
- Returning Lost Items: The Mitzvah of Hashavat Aveidah
- Keeping Your Word: Promises in Jewish Life
- Lashon Hara: The Jewish Laws of Gossip and Kind Speech
- Ona'at Devarim: The Mitzvah Not to Hurt People With Words
- How to Give Criticism Kindly: The Jewish Way
- Forgiveness and Making Peace: How to Apologize and How to Forgive
- Forgiving Yourself: What Judaism Teaches About Guilt and Starting Again
- Starting Over After You Fall: Tanya on Fresh Starts
- Changing a Bad Habit: Jewish Wisdom for Real Change
- Cheshbon HaNefesh: A Jewish Way to Take Stock of Your Life
- What Is the Yetzer Hara? Judaism on the Inner Struggle and How to Win It
- Mind Over Heart: Tanya's Key to Self-Control
- The Beinoni: The Tanya's Hero Is Someone Like You
- Why Do I Still Struggle? Tanya on the Inner Battle That Never Ends
Questions about this, or something on your mind? Message the Rabbi or the Rebbetzin privately, or call 925-384-7242. · Email
Read next
The Beinoni: The Tanya's Hero Is Someone Like YouWhat is a beinoni in the Tanya? The "intermediate person" who still feels the pull of temptation but never acts on it, a level open to everyone.Read next →