5th of Kislev, 5787 · Shabbat candles Fri, Nov 20 4:35 PM · Parashat Vayetzei
Chabad of Lamorinda

Learn › Jewish ideas › Maaser and the blessing of giving

King Munbaz: "My Fathers Stored Treasures Below, I Store Them Above"

The Talmud story of King Munbaz, who gave away his royal treasures in a famine, and what it teaches about what we truly keep. Read it and ask the Rabbi.

On this page · 3 min readThe story as the Talmud tells itWhat "above" means"I stored souls"Why this story matters for a legacy

King Munbaz was a ruler who, according to the Talmud (Bava Batra 11a), gave away his own treasures and those of his ancestors to feed the poor in years of hunger. When his family protested, he answered: "My fathers stored treasures below; I store them above." The story teaches that what we give to others is what we truly keep.

The story as the Talmud tells it

There were years of famine, and King Munbaz opened his storehouses. The Talmud tells that he spent the wealth he had inherited, together with the treasures his forefathers had gathered, to feed the poor.

His brothers and his father's household were upset. They told him, in effect: your ancestors saved and added to what their ancestors saved, and you are throwing it all away.

His reply is one of the most quoted lines about giving. As the Talmud tells it, he said that his ancestors stored below and he stored above; they stored in a place where a foreign hand can reach, and he in a place where no hand can reach; they stored things that bear no fruit, and he stored things that bear fruit; they stored money, and he stored souls; they stored for this world, and he stored for the World to Come.

What "above" means

Money kept in a vault can be lost, taxed, stolen or spent by someone else. A good deed cannot. Judaism teaches that a person's mitzvot and acts of kindness are what truly go with them. Tzedakah (צְדָקָה, "justice," what we call charity) turns something material into something lasting.

Notice also what King Munbaz did not say. He did not say that wealth is bad. He used his wealth, and his family's, for the best possible purpose. The Jewish view of wealth is that money is a tool entrusted to us, and it becomes valuable when it helps a life.

"I stored souls"

One of his phrases deserves a second look: "my ancestors stored money, and I stored souls." Feeding the hungry in a famine keeps people alive. Giving to Jewish education keeps a people alive. Both are ways of investing in living souls rather than in objects.

Why this story matters for a legacy

A legacy gift, whether in a will, a trust, a retirement account or life insurance, is a way of choosing in advance what "above" will mean for you. It asks one gentle question: of everything I will one day leave, what part do I want to be doing good after me?

For Chabad of Lamorinda, a gift of this kind is education for future generations, keeping Judaism alive and strengthening Jewish continuity for families in Lafayette, Moraga and Orinda. Chabad of Lamorinda accepts legacy gifts (a bequest in a will or trust, a retirement account or life insurance), donor-advised fund grants and gifts of stock. You can read how it works on the legacy page. Details such as legal wording and tax questions belong with your attorney and tax advisor; this guide is not legal or tax advice.

No one should feel pressure here. Giving is a personal matter, and the Rabbi and Rebbetzin are happy simply to talk.

In Lamorinda: Thinking about what you will leave behind? Talk it over with Rabbi Labkowski at 925-384-7242, or reach him at /help/talk-to-the-rabbi.

Common questions

Who was King Munbaz?

King Munbaz is a ruler mentioned in the Talmud (Bava Batra 11a) as one who gave away his treasures to feed the poor in years of famine. The story is told for its lesson about giving, not for history.

What did King Munbaz mean by "I stored them above"?

He meant that his ancestors saved money where it could be lost or taken, while he turned his wealth into good deeds that last. The Talmud adds that he stored "souls" and "for the World to Come."

Does Judaism say we should give away everything?

No. Jewish law sets a standard of giving a tenth, with up to a fifth especially praiseworthy; see Maaser. The story shows a spirit of generosity, not a rule for everyone. About maaser itself, the Torah makes a promise: in Malachi (3:10) G-d says to bring the tithes and "test Me," and the Talmud (Taanit 9a) teaches "give a tenth so that you will become rich." G-d promises success for all giving; maaser is unique because the promise is stated clearly and we are invited to test it. For your own situation, or if times are hard, call the Rabbi at 925-384-7242.

Can I include Chabad of Lamorinda in my will?

Yes. Chabad of Lamorinda accepts bequests in a will or trust, retirement accounts, life insurance, donor-advised fund grants and gifts of stock. Call Rabbi Yisroel Labkowski at 925-384-7242 or Rebbetzin Tzipora Labkowski at 925-384-7241, and see /legacy. Your attorney and tax advisor will help with the legal details.

Is a donor-advised fund grant considered maaser?

Yes. A donor-advised fund grant to Chabad of Lamorinda counts as maaser. To arrange one, call 925-384-7242.

Where can I read more stories about giving?

Start with Charity saves from death: two true Talmud stories and the best investment.

Take the next step

  • Read how a man planted a tree for children he might never meet: Choni and the carob tree.
  • Learn the ways to leave a gift: Leaving a Jewish legacy.
  • Call the Rabbi at 925-384-7242 or the Rebbetzin at 925-384-7241 to talk, with no pressure, about what you would like to leave for Jewish life in Lamorinda.

Questions about this, or something on your mind? Message the Rabbi or the Rebbetzin privately, or call 925-384-7242. · Email

Every week, free

Get the weekly email

Shabbat times, upcoming events, the Torah portion in two minutes, a guide to read, a mitzvah and a smile. Unsubscribe any time.