Learn › Jewish ideas › Jewish history and great figures

Choni and the Carob Tree: Planting for the Next Generation
The Talmud story of Choni and the carob tree: why we plant for children we may never meet, and how that connects to the legacy we leave. Read and reflect.
The story of Choni and the carob tree is told in the Talmud (Taanit 23a): a man plants a carob tree that will not bear fruit for seventy years, because, as he explains, his ancestors planted for him and he plants for those who come after. It is a Jewish classic about leaving something good for children you may never meet.
The story
Choni HaMe'agel ("the circle-maker") was walking along a road when he saw an old man planting a carob tree. In the Talmud's story, Choni asked him how long it would take to bear fruit. The man answered: seventy years.
Choni asked, "Do you expect to live seventy more years and eat its fruit?"
The man replied that he had found carob trees already standing in the world. Just as his ancestors had planted for him, he was planting for those who would follow.
What the planter understood
The old man did not plant for himself. He saw his life as one link in a chain: someone planted before him, and he would plant for someone after. Every one of us eats from trees we did not plant. Our Shabbat table, our prayers, our language, even the synagogue we walk into were given to us by people we never met.
Teachers apply the image in a few ways. Rabbi Mordechai Lightstone, in "Nine Ways to Be Like a Tree," uses the story to teach that we should bring sweetness into other people's lives even when the seeds we plant take many years to bear fruit. Another article, "The Old Man and the Fig Tree" by Rabbi Elisha Greenbaum, tells a similar midrash about an old man planting a fig tree for his children and points out that planting is an act of faith: the planter cannot control or follow the outcome.
What it means for us
You do not need to be wealthy to plant. A planter can be:
- A grandparent who tells a grandchild about the family's Jewish story (see Recording Your Family Story).
- A parent who writes a letter of values for the children (see An Ethical Will).
- A neighbor who volunteers, hosts a Shabbat meal or sponsors a child's Jewish education.
- Someone who plans a gift in their will, so that Jewish learning grows long after them. See Leaving a Jewish Legacy.
For Chabad of Lamorinda, the "trees" are Jewish education for future generations, keeping Judaism alive and strengthening Jewish continuity for families in Lafayette, Moraga and Orinda. Chabad of Lamorinda accepts legacy gifts (a bequest in a will or trust, a retirement account, life insurance), donor-advised fund grants and gifts of stock. See the legacy page. Legal and tax questions are for your attorney and tax advisor.
In Lamorinda: Wondering what you could plant for the next generation of Lamorinda? Call Rabbi Labkowski at 925-384-7242 or write through /help/talk-to-the-rabbi.
Common questions
What is the story of Choni and the carob tree?
It is a Talmud story (Taanit 23a) about Choni, who sees a man planting a carob tree that takes seventy years to bear fruit. The man explains that he is planting for his descendants, as his ancestors planted for him.
What is the lesson of the carob tree story?
We benefit from what earlier generations gave us, and we owe the same to those who come after. Teachers also draw from it patience and faith: do good even when you will not see the result.
Is this a Tu BiShvat story?
It is a story about a tree, but its message about planting for the future belongs to every season.
How can I plant for the next generation today?
You can teach, share your story, write an ethical will, support Jewish education or include a gift in your will. Each is a way of planting.
Can I leave a gift to Chabad of Lamorinda?
Yes. Chabad of Lamorinda accepts legacy gifts, donor-advised fund grants and gifts of stock. Call Rabbi Yisroel Labkowski at 925-384-7242 or Rebbetzin Tzipora Labkowski at 925-384-7241, or see /legacy.
Do I have to decide right away?
No. Talk it over with your family and your advisors first; the Rabbi is glad to listen with no pressure.
Take the next step
- Read real stories of people who planted for the future: True stories of legacy gifts.
- Write something for your children: An Ethical Will.
- Call the Rabbi at 925-384-7242 or the Rebbetzin at 925-384-7241 to ask what could grow from your gift.
Questions about this, or something on your mind? Message the Rabbi or the Rebbetzin privately, or call 925-384-7242. · Email
Read next
True Stories of Legacy Gifts That Kept Judaism AliveReal stories of people who left gifts in their wills for Jewish life, in their own words, and how you can leave a legacy in Lamorinda.Read next →