Learn › Jewish ideas › Tanya: your inner life

Is the Animal Soul Bad? Tanya on Your Natural Self
Is the animal soul evil? Tanya says it has good traits and can be raised up. Learn how your drive and energy can serve something higher.
On this page · 2 min read
What Chapter 1 saysRaising up the naturalSo what do I do with my desires?A noteNo: according to the Tanya, the animal soul is not simply bad. It is your natural self, with energy and drive, and it also has good traits such as compassion and kindness. The goal is not to crush it but to turn its power toward good.
This changes how many people see their own struggle. You do not have to hate the part of you that wants things.
What Chapter 1 says
In Chapter 1 the Tanya describes the animal soul and the pulls it can bring, such as anger, pride, love of pleasure and laziness. Then it says that the Jewish animal soul also produces good natural traits, such as compassion and kindness. As the Tanya explains in this chapter, this is because it comes from kelipat nogah, a realm that contains good. See the glossary and the two souls.
Raising up the natural
Chapter 37 of the Tanya goes further. It teaches that when you use physical things for a mitzvah, they are raised into holiness. The parchment of tefillin, an etrog and money given to tzedakah are examples. Things connected with a sin, like stolen money, cannot be raised in this way.
The same chapter says the animal soul itself is raised when it is used for a mitzvah:
- Speech: when you speak words of Torah or prayer aloud, you use the body and the animal soul, and so bring that energy into holiness.
- Food and drink: the energy that comes from food is raised when it is used for mitzvot. See eating as a mitzvah.
- Charity: the chapter says tzedakah is equal to all the other mitzvot together, because the giver's entire energy of earning goes into it. See tzedakah.
The chapter also says the soul's purpose in coming down into the world is to refine the body and the animal soul, and to unite them with G-d. See what is holiness?.
So what do I do with my desires?
The beinoni of Chapter 12 still feels the pull of the animal soul, but chooses what to do. Chassidic teaching explains that this struggle is the point, and that old temptations lose their pull while new ones appear. See the beinoni and mind over heart.
This does not mean that every desire is fine to follow. Case by case, ask the Rabbi.
A note
This is spiritual guidance. If a drive such as eating, spending or anger feels out of control, please also speak with a professional.
In Lamorinda: Want to explore this idea with others? Join the Wednesday 1:00 PM Tanya class in Lafayette, or call Rabbi Labkowski at 925-384-7242.
Common questions
Is the animal soul evil in Tanya?
No. Chapter 1 says it also has good natural traits, such as compassion and kindness, and Chapter 37 says it can be raised up through mitzvot.
What is kelipat nogah?
It is a mixed realm of good and evil, which contains good. Tanya says the Jewish animal soul comes from it, and that physical things from this realm can be raised through a mitzvah.
Should I try to destroy my natural desires?
The Tanya's aim is to refine and raise the animal soul, not to crush it. For personal questions, ask the Rabbi.
How can eating or working be holy?
Chapter 37 teaches that the energy gained from food and drink is raised when it is used for mitzvot. See eating as a mitzvah.
Does feeling temptation mean I am bad?
No. The beinoni still feels it and chooses what to do. See the beinoni.
Where can I talk about this in Lafayette, Moraga or Orinda?
At the Tanya class in English, every Wednesday at 1:00 PM at the Rabbi's home in Lafayette. Call Rabbi Labkowski at 925-384-7242 for the address.
Take the next step
- Read a part of G-d above, about the other soul.
- Read mind over heart for the tool of the struggle.
- Call 925-384-7242 or come to the Wednesday 1:00 PM class.
Questions about this, or something on your mind? Message the Rabbi or the Rebbetzin privately, or call 925-384-7242. · Email
Read next
A Part of G-d Above: What Tanya Says About Your SoulWhat does Tanya mean that the soul is "a part of G-d above"? Chapter 2 explained simply, with the breath image and what it means for you.Read next →