5th of Kislev, 5787 · Shabbat candles Fri, Nov 20 4:35 PM · Parashat Vayetzei
Chabad of Lamorinda

Learn › Jewish ideas › Maaser and the blessing of giving

Donor-Advised Funds, Stock and Maaser: Common Questions About Modern Giving

Does a donor-advised fund grant count as maaser? Yes. A plain guide to maaser, stock gifts, the questions to bring to your Rabbi, and where to start.

On this page · 3 min readWhat maaser isWhat counts as incomeThe questions about modern givingA simple way to prepareGiving to Chabad of Lamorinda

Chabad of Lamorinda accepts donor-advised fund grants and gifts of stock. A grant from a donor-advised fund counts as maaser (the tithe, usually a tenth of income given to tzedakah), as Rabbi Yisroel Labkowski has confirmed. A legacy gift counts as maaser too. Chabad of Lamorinda has a Fidelity brokerage account for gifts of stock. To arrange a grant or a gift of stock, call Rabbi Yisroel Labkowski at 925-384-7242 or Rebbetzin Tzipora Labkowski at 925-384-7241, and we will give you the transfer details. The classic guides to maaser do not address donor-advised funds or gifts of stock directly. What they do teach is a clear set of rules about intention, timing and who may receive maaser, and those rules show which questions to ask.

What maaser is

Maaser (מַעֲשֵׂר) means "a tenth." Maaser kesafim, giving a tenth of income, is the common practice, and giving up to a fifth (chomesh) is praiseworthy. It is a structured system, unlike tzedakah in general, which has no fixed percentage. See Maaser.

Most opinions hold that maaser is not biblically mandated, so it may often be used for other mitzvahs and not only for the poor. Poor people are still the primary recipients, and poor relatives come first.

What counts as income

For maaser, income includes salary, gifts, inheritance and interest. It does not include money you must repay, such as a loan. Investment gains count only once they are realized, for example when an asset is sold and the profit is received. Ideally, maaser is set aside when income is received, but it can also be calculated at any point during the year.

This matters for stock and other investments: the guide treats the gain as income when it is actually realized. How that works for a particular gift of stock, with a particular history, is a question for your tax advisor, and whether it counts as maaser is a question for the Rabbi.

The questions about modern giving

Does a donor-advised fund (DAF) count? Yes. Rabbi Labkowski has confirmed that a donor-advised fund grant counts as maaser. The classic maaser guides do not discuss DAFs, but a grant recommended from your fund to Chabad of Lamorinda counts toward your tenth. Chabad of Lamorinda accepts donor-advised fund grants; call the Rabbi or the Rebbetzin to arrange one.

Does giving stock count? The classic guides mention only that investment gains count as income once realized. Chabad of Lamorinda accepts gifts of stock through its Fidelity brokerage account. Please ask the Rabbi how it counts as maaser, and your tax advisor about taxes.

Can I use maaser to pay a pledge? Maaser can cover a pledge only if you intended to use maaser when you made the pledge. A pledge made without that intent must come from regular funds.

Can I use maaser for something I am already required to do? One example is Purim's required gifts to the poor (matanot la'evyonim), which must come from regular funds; using maaser for your own Torah learning is also problematic. Best practice is to use your own money for mitzvahs when you can and reserve maaser for charity.

A simple way to prepare

  1. Decide your intention first. Is this gift maaser, or from other funds?
  2. Write down the details, such as the date, the amount and whether it is a pledge.
  3. Keep records for your tax advisor. Tax questions belong with your tax advisor and your attorney, not in this guide.
  4. Ask your Rabbi before the gift, not after.

Giving to Chabad of Lamorinda

The giving page accepts gifts once or monthly. Chabad of Lamorinda accepts grants from donor-advised funds and gifts of stock, and can also be named as a beneficiary in your plans; a legacy gift counts as maaser. To arrange a grant or a gift of stock, contact Rabbi Yisroel Labkowski at 925-384-7242 or Rebbetzin Tzipora Labkowski at 925-384-7241. The legacy page lists ways to include Chabad of Lamorinda in your plans, including the tax ID your advisor or fund will ask for. Ask your tax advisor about the tax side.

In Lamorinda: Have a question about maaser, stock or a donor-advised fund? Call Rabbi Labkowski at 925-384-7242.

Common questions

Can maaser go to a donor-advised fund?

Yes. A donor-advised fund grant counts as maaser, as Rabbi Labkowski has confirmed, and Chabad of Lamorinda accepts these grants. To arrange one, contact Rabbi Yisroel Labkowski (925-384-7242) or Rebbetzin Tzipora Labkowski (925-384-7241).

Does a gift of stock count as tzedakah?

Chabad of Lamorinda accepts gifts of stock through its Fidelity brokerage account; call 925-384-7242 for the transfer details. How the value of a gift of stock is counted for maaser is a question for the Rabbi. Ask your tax advisor about taxes.

Do I have to give maaser if I am struggling?

No. Basic needs come first, and you are not obligated to give maaser if you cannot cover them. The Rebbe encouraged giving a partial amount when needed. Ask the Rabbi. See Giving Tzedakah When Money Is Tight.

Is maaser calculated on gross or net income?

Mandatory withholdings such as income tax and Social Security can be deducted, but personal living expenses are not. Ask the Rabbi for your situation.

Can I give at the end of the year?

Many people do. See Year-End Tzedakah.

Who can receive maaser?

Poor people are the primary recipients, and communal institutions such as a synagogue are also permitted. Ask the Rabbi about your cause.

Take the next step

  • Write down your maaser question and bring it to the Rabbi: call 925-384-7242. To give from a donor-advised fund or with stock, call the same number.
  • Read Maaser and Tzedakah Priorities for the basics.
  • Families in Lafayette, Moraga and Orinda can also see local giving.

Questions about this, or something on your mind? Message the Rabbi or the Rebbetzin privately, or call 925-384-7242. · Email

Every week, free

Get the weekly email

Shabbat times, upcoming events, the Torah portion in two minutes, a guide to read, a mitzvah and a smile. Unsubscribe any time.