5th of Kislev, 5787 · Shabbat candles Fri, Nov 20 4:35 PM · Parashat Vayetzei
Chabad of Lamorinda

Learn › Life cycle › Family life: hard moments

Discipline With Love: Jewish Wisdom on Setting Limits for Children

How to discipline children with love: stay calm, keep it short, set clear limits and ask for help. Jewish parenting wisdom.

On this page · 2 min readDiscipline teaches, it does not punishFirm hand, warm handPractical stepsParents of young children and teensWhen you lose your temper

Jewish wisdom teaches that discipline should come from love, not anger: be firm and clear about limits, but warm, calm and brief. Discipline is meant to teach a child self-control, not to punish.

Discipline teaches, it does not punish

Limits are like a railing on a boat: they give a child security so that he or she can explore. The goal is a child who learns self-control and understands that actions have consequences. Punishment, on the other hand, can breed resentment and teach a child only to avoid getting caught. Parents in Lafayette, Moraga and Orinda face the same challenges as parents everywhere, and these ideas help.

Firm hand, warm hand

The Talmud (Sanhedrin 107b) teaches that the left hand should push away while the right hand draws close. Teachers often explain this to parents as: correct with the weaker hand, embrace with the stronger. Warmth should always outweigh correction. Ask the Rabbi if you want to learn more.

Practical steps

  1. Wait until you are calm. Discipline must come from love, not anger, and should be planned, not impulsive. One idea attributed to the Rebbe: imagine the children are a neighbor's, entrusted to you by G-d for a time. You would not lose control with them.
  2. Keep it short. A scolding of about a minute is enough. Long lectures get tuned out.
  3. Speak about the behavior, not the child. Say "That was untrue," not "You are a liar."
  4. Stay factual. Describe what needs fixing and how.
  5. Be firm. Pleading and begging weaken a limit. Children need a parent who is a loving leader.
  6. Fill the tank. Playing, listening and affection prevent many problems. Notice and praise good behavior often.

Parents of young children and teens

With little ones, keep rules few, clear and the same every day. With teens, explain the reasons, listen, and choose your battles; see parents and teenagers. Values are learned mostly by watching the adults a child loves, so model the behavior you hope to see.

When you lose your temper

Everyone does sometimes, and an occasional lapse in a loving home is human. Apologize, and try again tomorrow. If outbursts are frequent, or children are being harmed, seek professional help right away. Read more in anger: the Jewish view. This guide gives no halachic rulings; for your family's situation, ask the Rabbi.

In Lamorinda: Parenting is hard. Talk privately with the Rabbi or Rebbetzin at /help/talk-to-the-rabbi or call 925-384-7242.

Common questions

What is the Jewish view on disciplining children?

Discipline should come from love, not anger, and should aim to teach self-control. It is firm, brief and warm.

Should parents punish in anger?

No. Discipline must come from love and be planned, not done in the heat of the moment. Wait until you are calm.

How long should a scolding be?

About one minute. Longer talks lose a child's attention and can harm self-esteem.

What does "left hand pushes away, right hand draws close" mean?

It is a Talmudic image for parenting: correct gently and briefly, and draw the child close with love. Ask the Rabbi to learn more.

What if I yell too much?

Occasional lapses are human; apologize and try again. If it is frequent, seek professional help and talk to the Rabbi or Rebbetzin.

Is there Jewish parenting support in Lamorinda?

Yes. Read about Jewish parenting, or call 925-384-7242 at Chabad of Lamorinda in Lafayette to talk privately.

Take the next step

Questions about this, or something on your mind? Message the Rabbi or the Rebbetzin privately, or call 925-384-7242. · Email

Every week, free

Get the weekly email

Shabbat times, upcoming events, the Torah portion in two minutes, a guide to read, a mitzvah and a smile. Unsubscribe any time.