5th of Kislev, 5787 · Shabbat candles Fri, Nov 20 4:35 PM · Parashat Vayetzei
Chabad of Lamorinda

Learn › Shabbat & holidays › Chanukah away from home

Chanukah in the Hospital: Lighting the Menorah for a Patient or Family

Chanukah when you or a loved one is in the hospital: why flames are not allowed, what to do instead and how to bring light to the room.

On this page · 3 min readWhy can't a patient light a flame in the hospital?Options for a patientWhat a visit can bringHelp in Lafayette, Moraga, Orinda and the East Bay

Hospitals do not allow open flames, so a patient cannot light a real menorah in a hospital room. Jewish law puts health and safety first, and it offers gentle options: a family member lights at home, a battery or electric menorah brings the light into the room without the blessings, and visitors bring Chanukah warmth with songs, stories and presence.

Why can't a patient light a flame in the hospital?

Fire in a room with oxygen and medical equipment is dangerous, and a hospital's rules are there to protect every patient. Judaism agrees: saving and guarding life overrides almost everything else, and no one is asked to risk their own safety or anyone else's to light a menorah.

The mitzvah of Chanukah (חֲנֻכָּה) is to kindle lights with fuel, wick and flame. Electric lights generally do not fulfill it, and where a flame truly is not possible, you should ask a rabbi. A battery-powered light may be considered in difficult circumstances, but the blessings are not recited over it.

Options for a patient

  1. Light at home, with the patient in mind. A spouse or relative lights a real menorah at home. A call that evening, or a photo of the lights, lets the patient feel part of it. Whether the patient fulfills the mitzvah through someone else's lighting depends on the situation, so ask the Rabbi.
  2. A battery menorah by the bed. Many families place a small electric or battery menorah near the bed, if the hospital allows it. It does not take the place of the mitzvah and is lit without blessings, but it brings the holiday into the room.
  3. A lighting in a lobby or prayer room. Some hospitals may have a menorah in a shared space. Ask the nurse or the hospital's spiritual care office; whether any flame is allowed is the hospital's decision.
  4. Songs and words. Sing Haneirot Halalu or Maoz Tzur, say a few words of the story, and let the patient simply listen. Even a short moment helps.
  5. Prayer and Tehillim. If it is comforting, say a chapter of Tehillim together, or send a name to the prayer list.

What a visit can bring

Chanukah is a holiday of bringing light into dark places. Here is a daughter's memory of a Chanukah when her father was in intensive care. Candles were not allowed, so her mother brought an electric menorah and set it on a shelf across from his bed, where he and the nurses could see it. That small light stayed with the family for years. It shows that a modest light, offered with love, matters.

If you visit a patient this Chanukah:

Help in Lafayette, Moraga, Orinda and the East Bay

Rabbi and Rebbetzin Labkowski visit the sick at home, in the hospital and in care facilities. If someone you love is in the hospital, please call 925-384-7242 or write through Talk to the Rabbi. We cannot promise a specific visit time, but we will gladly hear from you. For practical help for a family, see Help for seniors and families, or ask for help.

In Lamorinda: If you or someone you love is in the hospital, Rabbi and Rebbetzin Labkowski visit the sick. Call 925-384-7242 or see /help/talk-to-the-rabbi.

Common questions

Can I light a Chanukah menorah in a hospital room?

No, hospitals do not allow open flames, and safety comes first. You can use a battery menorah if the hospital allows it, light at home, and sing and say the story with the patient.

Do I say the blessings over an electric menorah in the hospital?

No. The blessings are not said over electric or battery lights. They still bring the joy of the holiday into the room.

Can a spouse light at home for a patient in the hospital?

A family member can light at home, and the patient shares in the joy. Whether it counts as the patient's own lighting depends on the situation, so please ask the Rabbi.

What if I am the patient and cannot light at all?

You are not alone and you are not failing a mitzvah. Join by watching a family member light, singing the songs or listening. Call the Rabbi for guidance on your own situation.

Can I bring latkes or donuts to a hospital patient?

Only if the patient's diet allows it and the hospital approves. Check with the nurse first.

Will the Rabbi visit someone in the hospital?

Rabbi and Rebbetzin Labkowski visit the sick in the hospital, at home and in care facilities. Call 925-384-7242.

Take the next step

Questions about this, or something on your mind? Message the Rabbi or the Rebbetzin privately, or call 925-384-7242. · Email

Every week, free

Get the weekly email

Shabbat times, upcoming events, the Torah portion in two minutes, a guide to read, a mitzvah and a smile. Unsubscribe any time.