Stories and jokes › Faith and courage
A Life for a Life: Dr. Gisella Perl
We all know about the infamous Angel of Death, Dr. Josef Mengele, who stood at Auschwitz and, with one finger pointing right or left, personally decided the fate of countless Jews as they arrived. One way meant work and a chance at life. The other was a death sentence, and before long all that remained of those people was ashes.
Chaya was a young bride, married at nineteen. She didn't have much of a honeymoon, because soon after her wedding she and her husband found themselves in Auschwitz. Her new husband was sent one way and she the other, and it didn't take long for Chaya to realize that she was now a very young widow. A short while later she realized something else: she was carrying more than memories. She was carrying a child.
As soon as she shared the news, the women in the barracks warned her. "As soon as the Nazis find out you're pregnant, you're dead. And not only dead: Dr. Mengele will torture you and the baby with his medical experiments, and then you'll both be burned." Chaya wanted this child so badly, as a memorial to its father, but the women were adamant that in Auschwitz a pregnancy was a double death sentence. "Then what should I do?" she cried. "Don't worry, Chaya. We'll call Dr. Perl. She will look after you."
Dr. Gisella Perl, born and educated in Sighet, Transylvania, was now an inmate in Auschwitz. She was a gynecologist and obstetrician, and she was known as "the other doctor at Auschwitz." Where Mengele killed, Perl cured. He sent people to hell; she brought them healing, as best she could under the most impossible of circumstances.
Dr. Perl examined Chaya. "You are too far along now for an abortion," she told her. "We must hide your pregnancy, and when the time comes, I will do what I have to do to save your life." Chaya was young and still naive about life in Auschwitz. The older women had to explain to her that here there was simply no choice: Dr. Perl would have to deliver the baby and then suffocate it, otherwise mother and child would both be butchered.
The dreaded time came, and Chaya was taken into the latrine, crying, "Please save my baby. I'm begging you, Doctor, please!"
"Chaya'le, I too am a woman. I too am a Jew," said Dr. Perl. "And as a doctor and an obstetrician, I am committed to bringing life into the world. But tragically, this is the only way we can save your life. Every time the Nazis find a pregnant woman it's the same: double torture and double death. At least this way we can hope to save the mothers' lives. But Chaya'le, I promise you: if we ever get out of this hell, I will dedicate myself to bringing life into the world."
Miraculously, Chaya survived, and eventually she came to New York. In the 1950s she was living in Borough Park, then a fledgling Jewish neighborhood. She remarried, thank G-d, and before long she was expecting, and busy looking for an obstetrician.
One day, walking down the street in Borough Park, she noticed a sign: "Dr. G. Perl, Obstetrician." Could it be? Was it possible? Could this really be the same Dr. Perl from Auschwitz? Had she survived too, and did she live here as well? Chaya ran inside the building, looking for Dr. Perl's office. She opened the door and froze. Instantly the two women recognized each other and flew into each other's arms. They embraced and wept for a long time.
"Will you keep your promise to me?" asked Chaya. "I want you to deliver my baby!"
This time it was not in the filthy latrine of Auschwitz but in a clean, sterile delivery room at Maimonides Hospital in Brooklyn. As Dr. Perl brought Chaya's baby into the world, she shouted the words that became her trademark, her slogan and her battle cry every time she delivered a Jewish baby: "A life for a life!" In Auschwitz she had been forced to take life away; now, in America, she was restoring it. "Mazel tov! It's a boy! L'chaim, to life!"
"Yes," said Chaya. "I will call him Chaim, for Life."
It is estimated that over the war years Dr. Perl saved the lives of some 10,000 Jewish women in Auschwitz. And through the years, every time she delivered a Jewish baby, she shouted those words: "A life for a life!" She passed away in 1984. May her special soul rest in peace.
On Yom Kippur, we too want to shout: "A life for a life!"
More faith and courage
Read more about it
Holocaust Remembrance: Jewish Ways to RememberHow to remember the six million in a Jewish way: Kaddish, Yom HaShoah, the Tenth of Tevet, candles, learning, tzedakah and living Jewishly.
Yom Kippur for Beginners: Your First Day of AtonementA first-timer's guide to Yom Kippur: what the day means, the five things we refrain from, who should not fast, Kol Nidre, Yizkor, Neilah and what to wear.