Learn › Jewish ideas › Maaser and the blessing of giving

The Best Investment: Rabbi Akiva Buys Rabbi Tarfon a Share
Rabbi Tarfon gave Rabbi Akiva 4,000 gold coins to buy him land. The story of what Akiva really bought, and a Jewish view of lasting wealth.
On this page · 3 min read
The story as tradition tells itWhat Akiva understoodWhere it connectsPutting it into practiceRabbi Tarfon, a wealthy sage, gave his student Rabbi Akiva 4,000 gold coins to buy him durable property, and Akiva gave all of it to poor Torah scholars. When Tarfon asked where his land was, Akiva showed him a verse about giving to the poor and said that this was the everlasting property he had bought. The story is a classic answer to the question: what is the best investment?
The story as tradition tells it
Nissan Mindel, in his Gallery of Our Great, tells that Rabbi Tarfon was a rich man. His disciple and colleague, Rabbi Akiva, offered to buy him some lasting goods. Tarfon immediately handed over 4,000 gold coins.
Akiva gave the entire sum to poor Torah scholars. Some time later, Tarfon asked where the properties were that Akiva had purchased for him. Akiva brought him into the study hall, opened a Book of Psalms, and read until he reached the verse about giving to the poor. He said that these were the everlasting possessions he had bought for him.
Tarfon rose, kissed Akiva on the head, and called him his teacher in wisdom and his leader in conduct.
(Different sources give slightly different amounts for the money. We follow Nissan Mindel's telling.)
What Akiva understood
Land can be lost and coins can be spent. A good deed is not lost. Akiva understood that Tarfon's real need was not another estate but a way to make his wealth last, and he found the best "investment" available. He did it not for show but for his friend, and he waited until his friend asked before he explained. There is humility in that too: a good deed that does not need to announce itself.
Notice Tarfon's response. He could have been angry that his money was given away without his knowledge. Instead he saw the truth, thanked his friend and called him his teacher. The story honors both men: the one who gave wisely and the one who could hear a hard truth with humility.
Where it connects
- King Munbaz said much the same: his ancestors stored below, he stored above. See King Munbaz.
- The Jewish view of money is about what it does for others and for the soul. See A Jewish View of Wealth.
- The Sages such as Rabbi Akiva and Rabbi Tarfon are met in Pirkei Avot and Rabbi Akiva.
Putting it into practice
Not every gift needs to be large. Many Jews start with a fixed portion. About maaser, giving a tenth, the Torah makes a promise: G-d says through Malachi (3:10) to bring the tithes and "test Me," and the Talmud (Taanit 9a) teaches "give a tenth so that you will become rich." The Torah and G-d promise success for all giving; maaser is unique because the promise is stated clearly and we are invited to test it. See Maaser. In hard times, or for any personal question, call the Rabbi.
For something that continues beyond a lifetime, you can arrange a legacy gift: a bequest in a will or trust, a retirement account or life insurance. Chabad of Lamorinda accepts these, as well as donor-advised fund grants and gifts of stock, for education of future generations and Jewish continuity in Lafayette, Moraga and Orinda. See /legacy. Please consult your attorney and tax advisor on details.
In Lamorinda: Curious how to put your values to work? Call Rabbi Labkowski at 925-384-7242 or write through /help/talk-to-the-rabbi.
Common questions
Who were Rabbi Akiva and Rabbi Tarfon?
They were two Sages of the Talmud. Tarfon was wealthy, and Akiva was his disciple and colleague.
What did Rabbi Akiva do with Rabbi Tarfon's money?
He gave all of it to poor Torah scholars, as the story tells it.
What is the best investment in Judaism?
The Sages answer: good deeds, especially tzedakah and supporting Torah, because they last. Your own advisors can help with financial investments.
Was Rabbi Tarfon angry?
No. He kissed Rabbi Akiva on the head and called him his teacher.
What did Rabbi Akiva show Rabbi Tarfon?
A verse in Psalms about giving to the poor.
How do I start giving?
Begin with what you can, perhaps a regular amount. See Tzedakah, or call 925-384-7242.
Take the next step
- Read the earlier story, King Munbaz.
- Learn about the habit of giving: Maaser.
- Call Rabbi Labkowski at 925-384-7242 or Rebbetzin Labkowski at 925-384-7241 to talk about what you want your giving to build.
Questions about this, or something on your mind? Message the Rabbi or the Rebbetzin privately, or call 925-384-7242. · Email
Read next
King Munbaz: "My Fathers Stored Treasures Below, I Store Them Above"The Talmud story of King Munbaz, who gave away his royal treasures in a famine, and what it teaches about what we truly keep. Read it and ask the Rabbi.Read next →