Learn › Jewish ideas › Maaser and the blessing of giving

Mar Ukva and the Hidden Coins: A Talmud Story of Secret Giving
The Talmud story of Mar Ukva, who gave secretly to a poor neighbor and hid in an oven rather than shame him. What it teaches about dignity in giving.
On this page · 2 min read
The storyThe lesson: giving without taking a person's dignityWhat we can take from itIn LamorindaMar Ukva was a Talmudic sage who gave money to a poor neighbor in secret, and when the man came out to see who his benefactor was, Mar Ukva hid in an oven so as not to embarrass him. His reason, quoted in the Talmud (Ketubot 67b): it is better for a person to throw himself into an oven than to shame a colleague in public.
The story
The Talmud (Ketubot 67b) tells it: Mar Ukva used to leave money at a poor neighbor's doorstep every day. One day the man ran out to see who his benefactor was. Mar Ukva hid by going into an oven that was still warm but no longer burning. Asked why, he said that it is preferable for a person to cast himself into an oven than to embarrass a colleague in public.
The Talmud goes on: Mar Ukva's feet were burned, and he became known as "Mar Ukva with burnt feet." His wife hid with him and was not burned. The Talmud explains her merit as feeding poor people directly, while Mar Ukva gave money.
The lesson: giving without taking a person's dignity
The story is mainly about the person who receives. A gift can help, and it can also hurt, if it makes the receiver feel small. Mar Ukva was ready to go through a hot oven so that his neighbor never had to face his own need in front of someone else.
Maimonides ranks the levels of giving. The highest is helping someone before he falls into need, with a gift, a loan, a partnership or a job, so that he never has to ask. Giving where neither side knows the other is "an observance of the mitzvah for its sake alone." Partial secrecy, where only the giver or only the recipient knows, is also a level. For a how-to, see Giving Anonymously.
What we can take from it
- Think about the receiver. Ask how a gift will feel to the person who receives it.
- Do not announce. Giving quietly protects the receiver and keeps the giver humble.
- Never shame. The Talmud's principle applies far beyond charity. See Lashon Hara for the Jewish teaching on careful speech.
- Help the whole person. The story's second half, about the wife who fed people directly, reminds us that kindness can be a meal, a visit or a call, not only a check. See Chesed.
In Lamorinda
Needs exist in every town, including Lafayette, Moraga and Orinda, often unseen because people are private. If you or someone you know could use support, Chabad of Lamorinda has help for seniors and families and a private request form. If you would like to help others, see volunteering, or give to the Chesed Fund at /donate?fund=chesed#give to sponsor visits and help.
In Lamorinda: Want to help a neighbor with dignity? Talk it over with Rabbi Labkowski at 925-384-7242, or through /help/talk-to-the-rabbi.
Common questions
Who was Mar Ukva?
He was a sage of the Talmud, known for his generosity and for the story of secret giving told in Ketubot 67b.
Why did Mar Ukva hide in an oven?
So that the poor man he was helping would not discover who gave to him and be embarrassed. He said it is better to throw oneself into an oven than to shame a colleague in public.
Is it better to give anonymously?
Secret giving is a very high level, and giving in a way that spares the receiver's dignity matters most. Ask the Rabbi about specific situations.
What does the story teach about shame?
That embarrassing a person in public is extremely serious in Jewish teaching, and protecting someone's dignity is worth real effort.
How can I give to a neighbor without embarrassing them?
Consider giving through a trusted third party, or ask the Rabbi to advise. You can call 925-384-7242.
Can I give to Chabad of Lamorinda without my name being shown?
Call Rabbi Labkowski at 925-384-7242 to talk about how you would like to give.
Take the next step
- Read the practical side: Giving Anonymously.
- Continue with another Talmud story: Charity saves from death.
- Call the Rabbi at 925-384-7242 to ask how you can help someone nearby with dignity.
Questions about this, or something on your mind? Message the Rabbi or the Rebbetzin privately, or call 925-384-7242. · Email
Read next
Giving Anonymously: The Jewish Value of Quiet GenerosityIs it better to give charity anonymously? What Maimonides' levels of tzedakah teach about secret giving, dignity and humility, and how to give quietly.Read next →