Learn › Shabbat & holidays › Chanukah away from home

Chanukah in Senior Living and Care Homes: Lighting When Open Flames Are Not Allowed
Can you light a Chanukah menorah in assisted living or a care home that bans flames? Safe options, electric menorahs and who to ask.
On this page · 3 min read
What is the mitzvah, and why does a flame matter?Options when flames are not allowedMake Chanukah real even without a flameHow the Jewish community helpsMany assisted living and care homes do not allow open flames, so a real menorah is often not possible in a resident's room. Jewish law has good answers: light a real menorah in a place where it is allowed, let family light on the resident's behalf, and use an electric menorah to share the joy and publicize the miracle, but without the blessings.
What is the mitzvah, and why does a flame matter?
The mitzvah of Chanukah (חֲנֻכָּה) is to kindle lights in the evening, adding one each night, so that the miracle is seen. The menorah is meant to recall the lamp of the Holy Temple, so it should be a lamp with fuel, a wick and fire. Olive oil with cotton wicks is the ideal, and wax candles also work.
For that reason, an electric menorah generally does not fulfill the mitzvah. It is a lovely way to publicize the holiday, but it is not a replacement for fire. Everyone agrees that safety comes first, and Jewish law never asks anyone to endanger a life or a building.
Options when flames are not allowed
Here are the choices, from the best to the simplest. Please call the Rabbi if you are not sure which fits.
- Light in a place where it is allowed. Ask the staff whether a menorah may be lit in a dining room, activity room, prayer room or lobby, with a staff member present. Some facilities allow it. The lights should burn for about half an hour after nightfall; ask the Rabbi about the details of the timing.
- Light a real menorah at home on their behalf. A family member can light at home with the resident in mind, and a call that evening shares the joy. Whether the resident can fulfill the mitzvah through someone else's lighting depends on the situation, so ask the Rabbi.
- Use a safe flame if the home permits. Use tea lights (short, sturdy candles in a metal cup) on a fireproof tray, kept away from anything flammable. Never light in a place that forbids it, and never leave a flame unattended.
- An electric or battery menorah as a reminder. When no flame is possible, consult your rabbi. A battery-powered light may be used in difficult circumstances, but the blessings are not said over it. It brings the holiday into the room, and the resident can sing, say Haneirot Halalu and enjoy the glow.
Make Chanukah real even without a flame
- Sing. Songs such as Maoz Tzur and Haneirot Halalu bring back memories. See Chanukah songs.
- Taste. Latkes and donuts, if the resident's diet allows. Check with the staff about any dietary needs before bringing food. See Chanukah foods.
- Tell the story. Read the story of Chanukah aloud.
- Give gelt. The custom of gelt is a good way to include grandchildren. See Chanukah gelt and tzedakah.
- Be there. For a resident with memory loss, a menorah in the room can be a visual cue that the holiday has come. Your presence matters most.
How the Jewish community helps
Rabbi and Rebbetzin Labkowski visit people in care facilities, and Chabad of Lamorinda has help for seniors and families. If you would like to ask about a visit for your loved one in Lafayette, Moraga or Orinda, or in the East Bay, call 925-384-7242. We cannot promise a specific time, so please call early in the season. For the wider picture, see Jewish life in senior living and Jewish seniors in Lamorinda.
In Lamorinda: Rabbi and Rebbetzin Labkowski visit care facilities. To ask about Chanukah for your parent or yourself, see /help/help-for-seniors-and-families or call 925-384-7242.
Common questions
Can I light a Chanukah menorah in assisted living?
Only if the facility allows an open flame. Ask the staff first. If it is allowed, light with the blessings. If not, the family can light at home, or the facility may let you light in a common room. Ask the Rabbi if you are unsure.
Does an electric menorah count for Chanukah?
Electric lights generally do not fulfill the mitzvah, so the blessings are not said over them. They still publicize the miracle and bring joy, so many people place one in the window or room as a reminder.
Can my mother take part if her son or daughter lights for her?
Ask the Rabbi. When someone is truly present at a lighting, listening and answering "Amen," they can share in it. A lighting somewhere else is a different question, and the answer depends on the situation.
Is it safe to use tea lights for an elderly person?
Only with supervision. Tea lights on a fireproof surface are best, but for an elderly person living alone, ask the family and the Rabbi whether a flame is wise. Safety always comes first.
What if my parent has dementia?
The sight of lights, the songs and a familiar person at their side can bring back deep memories. Keep it short, calm and warm. Call the Rabbi if you would like help.
Does Chabad of Lamorinda visit care homes?
Rabbi and Rebbetzin Labkowski visit the sick and seniors in care facilities. To arrange or ask about a visit, call 925-384-7242 or use the help form.
Take the next step
- Read Bringing Chanukah to someone homebound for ideas on visits and calls.
- Ask for help, or offer it, at help for seniors and families or volunteer.
- Sponsor visits and help for others at the Chesed Fund.
Questions about this, or something on your mind? Message the Rabbi or the Rebbetzin privately, or call 925-384-7242. · Email
Read next
Bringing Chanukah to Someone Homebound: Visits, Calls and Gifts of LightHow to bring Chanukah to a homebound senior or friend: what to say on a visit, what to bring, lighting together, calls and ways to volunteer in Lamorinda.Read next →